Investing/Nov 18 edition/Reporting & analysis
StocksMarketsRegulation

StocksEquities, earnings & valuations

FT says crash forecasters are like a stopped clock, as chip stocks swing on Huang's exit and Nvidia's $115.8bn quarter

As AI chip stocks went through a post-midterm rout, Jensen Huang's abrupt resignation and a sharply higher Nvidia quarter, the FT argued that crash forecasters have been worrying for 170 years and, like a stopped clock, are bound to be right sometimes.

From the FT Alphaville article of November 18, 2026 and cited sources: The FT commentary makes a base-rate argument. [1]

SOURCES[1] When’s the crash? Ask a journalist ft.com

AI-assisted, not human-edited. Methodology Corrections Who owns this site

KEY FACTS
What happened
The FT commentary makes a base-rate argument. [1]
Original source
FT Alphaville article, independent perspective
Brief by
AT Pulse research desk AI-assisted; publisher and contact on the desk page
When
November 18, 2026 article published
Evidence
10 sources across 10 sites

Reach: not measured yet

THE CORE IDEAS4 TAKEAWAYS
01

The FT commentary makes a base-rate argument. Warnings of a crash have run for about 170 years, so some forecasters will eventually be right. Judging any crash call fairly means counting its misses as well as its hits. [1]

02

On 5 November chip stocks had their biggest one-day fall since March 2020. Reports put the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index's drop between 9.2% and more than 12%, depending on intraday versus closing figures. The Nasdaq 100 fell 6% and the S&P 500 fell 4.4%. Commentators linked the selloff to Democratic gains in Congress, but that link is opinion rather than established cause. [4] [8]

03

Huang resigned with immediate effect on 11 November, and Nvidia's filing gave no reason. His exit followed a board probe into reports that he had been the target of a foreign intelligence effort, which China denies. CFO Colette Kress is now interim CEO, and the board chair has said there are no plans to reinstate Huang. [2] [5] [6] [7]

04

Nvidia reported quarterly revenue of $115.8 billion, up 103% from a year earlier, with $107.6 billion from data centres. Its Q4 guidance of $130 billion assumes no data-centre compute sales to China. Revenue beat the consensus estimate of about $109 billion, though the figures are company-reported and unaudited. Shares rose 2.84% in premarket trading on 18 November. [3] [7]

WHY IT MATTERS

Prices and reported fundamentals moved apart: Nvidia's sales doubled while chip stocks fell on politics and leadership turmoil.

Read the full assessment

Compute buyers should plan for policy and export-control risk, and crash forecasts should be judged on full track records, misses included.

Executive brief

Nvidia's founder Jensen Huang resigned with immediate effect on 11 November, according to the company's SEC 8-K. Six days later Nvidia reported revenue of $115.8 billion, up 103% from a year earlier (Nvidia). Against this background, the FT commentary argues that people predicting a crash have been anxious for 170 years, so like a stopped clock they are right fairly often. Only the feed excerpt of the FT piece was available. Nothing independent confirms or tests its argument. Prices fell sharply while the reported fundamentals stayed strong.

Read the full section

Nvidia's founder Jensen Huang resigned with immediate effect on 11 November, according to the company's SEC 8-K. Six days later Nvidia reported revenue of $115.8 billion, up 103% from a year earlier (Nvidia). That came after the biggest one-day fall in chip stocks since March 2020. Against this background, the FT commentary argues that people predicting a crash have been anxious for 170 years, so like a stopped clock they are right fairly often. Only the feed excerpt of the FT piece was available. Nothing independent confirms or tests its argument. Prices fell sharply while the reported fundamentals stayed strong.

What changed and event timeline

  1. Chip rout after midterms

    The Philadelphia Semiconductor Index fell about 12%, the Nasdaq 100 fell 6% and the S&P 500 fell 4.4%. Investors were worried that Democratic control of Congress could slow data-centre spending ().

  2. 8–9 Nov 2026: Nvidia board opens a probe

    The board began an independent investigation into reports that Huang had been the target of a foreign intelligence effort. Shares fell more than 4%, to about $178.8 (;).

  3. Huang resigns

    The 8-K records his exit as president, CEO and director, with no reason given. CFO Colette Kress became interim CEO and Harvey C. Jones became board chair ().

  4. Q3 FY2027 results

    Revenue was $115.8 billion, data-centre revenue $107.6 billion and Q4 guidance $130 billion ±3%. The guidance assumes no data-centre compute revenue from China ().

  5. Relief and scepticism

    Nvidia rose 2.84% in premarket trading, and the neocloud companies CoreWeave and Nebius gained 3–4% (). The same morning the FT published its commentary on journalists' crash predictions ().

Capabilities and access

  • Nvidia says its Vera Rubin NVL72 platform has shipped (Nvidia).
  • The US Commerce Department announced measures to limit Chinese access to advanced Nvidia chips through overseas data centres (CNBC).
  • Practitioners get no new model or product access out of this story.
Read the full section
  • Nvidia says its Vera Rubin NVL72 platform has shipped (Nvidia).
  • Its outlook leaves out China. The US Commerce Department announced measures to limit Chinese access to advanced Nvidia chips through overseas data centres (CNBC).
  • Practitioners get no new model or product access out of this story. The story is about how much capital is going into compute and how reliable that supply is.

Technical analysis for researchers and developers

  • The size of the 5 Nov fall depends on the source. The gap reflects intraday versus closing figures and when each report was published.
  • The 9 November close is given as $178.83 in one report and $178.67 in another (Motley Fool; ABC7).
  • The FT's point is about base rates. A forecaster who predicts a crash every year will eventually be right.
Read the full section
  • The size of the 5 Nov fall depends on the source. Reports for the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index range from 9.2% to more than 12% (search compilation incl. StockTwits, IBTimes). The gap reflects intraday versus closing figures and when each report was published. Anyone building a dataset should use official closing prints.
  • Nvidia's prices differ slightly across outlets. The 9 November close is given as $178.83 in one report and $178.67 in another (Motley Fool; ABC7).
  • The FT's point is about base rates. A forecaster who predicts a crash every year will eventually be right. Judging any crash forecaster needs a track record that counts the misses as well as the hits.

Claims and evidence

  • The midterms caused the rout. This is market commentary, not established cause. JonesTrading's Michael O'Rourke called the policy change a "structural shift" (Star-Advertiser).
  • Huang was targeted by Chinese intelligence. This is an allegation from New York Times reporting, and China has denied it.
  • Nvidia's results are strong. The figures come from Nvidia's own reports and have not been audited.
Read the full section
  • The midterms caused the rout. This is market commentary, not established cause. JonesTrading's Michael O'Rourke called the policy change a "structural shift" (Star-Advertiser).
  • Huang was targeted by Chinese intelligence. This is an allegation from New York Times reporting, and China has denied it. Huang acknowledged only infidelity, in a message to staff, and the board said it had no reason to believe security had been compromised (ABC7; Motley Fool).
  • Nvidia's results are strong. The figures come from Nvidia's own reports and have not been audited. Revenue came in above the consensus estimate of about $109 billion (CNBC).

Context and prior work

  • Bloomberg's report quotes PenderFund's Greg Taylor saying he was getting "flashbacks" to 2001 and 2008 (Star-Advertiser).
  • After 2008, journalists and academics debated why so few financial journalists saw that crisis coming (journalism.co.uk; Talking Biz News). The FT piece appears to take the opposite angle: the press warns of crashes too often, not too rarely.
Read the full section
  • Bloomberg's report quotes PenderFund's Greg Taylor saying he was getting "flashbacks" to 2001 and 2008 (Star-Advertiser).
  • After 2008, journalists and academics debated why so few financial journalists saw that crisis coming (journalism.co.uk; Talking Biz News). The FT piece appears to take the opposite angle: the press warns of crashes too often, not too rarely.

Limitations, safety and contested findings

  • Only the FT's feed excerpt was available. Its full argument and any data behind it cannot be checked.
  • The espionage allegations have not been proven, and the board's investigation was still under way.
  • Huang has said he is open to returning. Board chair Jones said there are no plans to reinstate him (CNBC).
Read the full section
  • Only the FT's feed excerpt was available. Its full argument and any data behind it cannot be checked.
  • The espionage allegations have not been proven, and the board's investigation was still under way.
  • Huang has said he is open to returning. Board chair Jones said there are no plans to reinstate him (CNBC).
  • One premarket gain does not show that the selloff is over.

Business and practitioner implications

  • Price and fundamentals are moving apart. Valuations fell over politics and leadership turmoil while reported data-centre demand kept growing.
  • Policy risk is now in the price. Plans for data centres and compute purchases should allow for regulation and for China export controls (CNBC).
  • Key-person risk is real.
Read the full section
  • Price and fundamentals are moving apart. Valuations fell over politics and leadership turmoil while reported data-centre demand kept growing.
  • Policy risk is now in the price. Plans for data centres and compute purchases should allow for regulation and for China export controls (CNBC).
  • Key-person risk is real. A 33-year founder-CEO left with immediate effect, and the business is now run by an interim CEO who is also the CFO (SEC 8-K).
  • Treat crash calls with caution, as the FT suggests. Volatility does not by itself show that a bubble is bursting. Nothing here is investment advice.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

The source trail.

Sources (10)
A LITTLE LESS NOISE. A LOT MORE CONTEXT.

Stay curious.
Follow the evidence.

Independent perspectives, the original sources, and room for the questions that don't have easy answers.

How we build the brief
Connect with us

Find us where you already read.