Investing/Nov 17 edition/Reporting & analysis
Personal investingMacro

Personal investingPortfolios, retirement & planning

Analysis of Fed Survey Data Finds Only 3–9% of Households Meet Fidelity's Retirement Savings Multiples

Nick Maggiulli's analysis of the Federal Reserve's 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances finds that few households hit Fidelity's salary-multiple savings targets. He proposes replacing income multiples with a target based on spending, discounted back from projected retirement costs.

From the Of Dollars and Data article of November 17, 2026 and cited sources: The 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances puts the median retirement balance at $106k among households that have an account, up 11% since 2022. [2] [9] [5]

SOURCES[2] Federal Reserve: 2025 SCF press release federalreserve.gov[9] Fox Business: Fed survey shows retirement account gains foxbusiness.com[5] Yahoo/Investopedia: How Does Your Retirement Savings Stack… finance.yahoo.com

AI-assisted, not human-edited. Methodology Corrections Who owns this site

KEY FACTS
What happened
The 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances puts the median retirement balance at $106k among households that have an account, up 11% since 2022. [2] [9] [5]
Original source
Of Dollars and Data article, independent perspective
Brief by
AT Pulse research desk AI-assisted; publisher and contact on the desk page
When
November 17, 2026 article published
Evidence
10 sources across 8 sites

Reach: not measured yet

How Much Should You Have Saved for Retirement by Age?
Image: Of Dollars And Data — Original article ↗
THE CORE IDEAS3 TAKEAWAYS
01

The 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances puts the median retirement balance at $106k among households that have an account, up 11% since 2022. Participation held at about 65%, and roughly 35–42% of households at several ages have no retirement account. [2] [9] [5]

02

Maggiulli compared retirement balances with income for households earning at least $20k. The median ratio was below 1x salary at every age, and only about 3–9% of households, depending on age, met Fidelity's milestones (1x by 30 up to 10x by 67). He reads this as partly a savings shortfall and partly a sign that salary multiples are the wrong yardstick. [1] [8]

03

His proposed Current Retirement Need starts with yearly spending not covered by other income. It multiplies that by 25, which assumes a 4% withdrawal rate, then discounts it at a 5% real return. Small changes in assumptions move the result a lot. Over 31 years the discount factor is about 4.5. Morningstar's 3.9% base-case withdrawal rate would raise the multiplier to about 25.6. His assumed 25% Social Security cut is close to the roughly 22% shortfall projected for the retirement trust fund after 2032. [1] [3] [4]

WHY IT MATTERS

Fed data show a $106k median among account holders, yet the post's analysis finds most households below common salary-multiple rules.

Read the full assessment

If those rules misjudge readiness, planners and product teams may need tools built on spending, Social Security and return assumptions.

Executive brief

The 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances shows that the median balance among U.S. households with a retirement account is $106k. In a post on Of Dollars and Data, Nick Maggiulli works through the SCF microdata and estimates that only about 3–9% of households, depending on age, reach Fidelity's salary-multiple savings benchmarks. He reads that as partly a savings problem and partly a sign that income multiples are the wrong yardstick. In their place he proposes a target based on spending: the money needed today, discounted back from what retirement will cost. The post is commentary, and the 3–9% figure is his own calculation.

What changed and event timeline

  1. The 4% rule gets a revised number

    Boldin's summary of puts the base-case safe starting withdrawal rate at 3.9%. Flexible spending approaches could support up to 5.7%.

  2. Trustees bring forward the OASI shortfall

    The retirement trust fund now runs out in Q4 2032. After that, payroll taxes would cover about 78% of scheduled benefits unless Congress acts ().

  3. The Fed releases the 2025 SCF

    Real median family income rose 7% to $82,200 and median net worth rose 2% to $215,900. Retirement plan participation stayed at about 65% ().

  4. Age breakdowns appear

    Investopedia's analysis of the SCF puts median balances among account holders at $12,600 for households in their 20s and $250,000 for those in their 60s–70s. Households in their 30s were the only age group where account ownership fell ().

  5. Maggiulli publishes post 529

    He compares SCF data with Fidelity's multiples and proposes a "Current Retirement Need" metric ().

Capabilities and access

  • Data: the public microdata and summary report for the 2025 SCF. The survey is run by NORC and the report PDF covers changes from 2022 to 2025.
  • Code: the author says the post's code is in his GitHub repository under post number 529.
  • Benchmark: Fidelity's guideline is 1x salary by age 30, 3x by 40, 6x by 50, 8x by 60 and 10x by 67.
Read the full section
  • Data: the public microdata and summary report for the 2025 SCF. The survey is run by NORC and the report PDF covers changes from 2022 to 2025.
  • Code: the author says the post's code is in his GitHub repository under post number 529.
  • Benchmark: Fidelity's guideline is 1x salary by age 30, 3x by 40, 6x by 50, 8x by 60 and 10x by 67. The in-between milestones in the post (2x at 35, 4x at 45, 7x at 55) do not appear on the Fidelity page reviewed.

Technical analysis for researchers and developers

  • Benchmark-hit rate: the post divides retirement account balances by income for households earning at least $20k, then reports the 25th, 50th, 75th and 90th percentiles by age.
  • Proposed metric: Current Need = (uncovered annual spending × 25) ÷ 1.05^years. That builds in a 4% withdrawal rate and a 5% real return.
  • Sensitivity: with 31 years to go, the 5% real-return assumption compounds into a factor of about 4.5.
Read the full section
  • Benchmark-hit rate: the post divides retirement account balances by income for households earning at least $20k, then reports the 25th, 50th, 75th and 90th percentiles by age. The median ratio is below 1x at every age.
  • Proposed metric: Current Need = (uncovered annual spending × 25) ÷ 1.05^years. That builds in a 4% withdrawal rate and a 5% real return. The author's example works out: $2.85M ÷ 1.05^31 ≈ $628k.
  • Sensitivity: with 31 years to go, the 5% real-return assumption compounds into a factor of about 4.5. Morningstar's 3.9% would mean multiplying spending by roughly 25.6 instead of 25.
  • Reproducibility: the age brackets differ between sources. The post uses ages 60–64 ($252k); Investopedia uses 60s–70s ($250k).

Claims and evidence

  • $106k conditional median, up 11% since 2022: confirmed by Fox Business reporting on Fed data.
  • At least 35% of households in every age bracket lack a retirement account: consistent with Investopedia's figure that about 37–42% of households at peak-earning and retirement ages have none (Yahoo/Investopedia).
  • Only 3–9% meet the benchmarks: this is the author's own calculation. No independent replication was found.
Read the full section
  • $106k conditional median, up 11% since 2022: confirmed by Fox Business reporting on Fed data.
  • At least 35% of households in every age bracket lack a retirement account: consistent with Investopedia's figure that about 37–42% of households at peak-earning and retirement ages have none (Yahoo/Investopedia).
  • Only 3–9% meet the benchmarks: this is the author's own calculation. No independent replication was found.
  • $5k median across all households: this figure is from the post's own analysis. It was not checked against the Fed summary.

Context and prior work

  • Fidelity's multiples assume a 15% savings rate, retirement at 67, more than 50% in stocks over a lifetime, and keeping the same lifestyle in retirement (Fidelity).
  • Fidelity already adjusts for some of what the post criticises.
  • The post's "save until you hit the target, then coast" logic is the Coast FIRE idea, which the author names himself.
Read the full section
  • Fidelity's multiples assume a 15% savings rate, retirement at 67, more than 50% in stocks over a lifetime, and keeping the same lifestyle in retirement (Fidelity).
  • Fidelity already adjusts for some of what the post criticises. It suggests about 8x for below-average spending, 12x for above-average spending, and 12x for retiring at 65.
  • The post's "save until you hit the target, then coast" logic is the Coast FIRE idea, which the author names himself.

Limitations, safety and contested findings

  • Social Security assumption: the author's 25% benefit haircut is close to Fortune's 22% cut for the retirement fund alone.
  • The 4% rule is disputed: Morningstar's base case is 3.9% (Boldin).
  • The SCF is a survey: it measures retirement accounts, not defined-benefit pensions. That leaves out part of older households' retirement resources.
Read the full section
  • Social Security assumption: the author's 25% benefit haircut is close to Fortune's 22% cut for the retirement fund alone. The Congressional Research Service reports that combined revenues would cover about 83% of benefits in 2034, falling to 65% by 2100. Which assumption fits depends on the scenario.
  • The 4% rule is disputed: Morningstar's base case is 3.9% (Boldin).
  • The SCF is a survey: it measures retirement accounts, not defined-benefit pensions. That leaves out part of older households' retirement resources.

Business and practitioner implications

  • For product teams: a planning tool built around spending needs inputs for expected spending, Social Security and return assumptions, not just salary.
  • For employers and policymakers: account ownership closely tracks income and job type (Federal Reserve), so access remains the gap with the biggest consequences.
  • For data teams: state the age brackets and income filters used. Different binnings of the same survey produce different medians.
Read the full section
  • For product teams: a planning tool built around spending needs inputs for expected spending, Social Security and return assumptions, not just salary. The answer shifts a lot when those assumptions change.
  • For employers and policymakers: account ownership closely tracks income and job type (Federal Reserve), so access remains the gap with the biggest consequences.
  • For data teams: state the age brackets and income filters used. Different binnings of the same survey produce different medians.

None of this is investment advice.

FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

The source trail.

Sources (10)
A LITTLE LESS NOISE. A LOT MORE CONTEXT.

Stay curious.
Follow the evidence.

Independent perspectives, the original sources, and room for the questions that don't have easy answers.

How we build the brief
Connect with us

Find us where you already read.