Funds & ETFsFlows, fees & vehicles
Hoffstein and Butler Argue for Stacking Managed Futures on Top of Stock-Bond Portfolios as AI Bubble and Inflation Fears Grow
Corey Hoffstein and Adam Butler argue investors worried about an AI-led stock selloff and inflation-driven bond losses can keep a full stock-bond portfolio and use futures to layer managed futures on top, though trend following just endured a deep drawdown.
From the Excess Returns podcast episode of November 12, 2026 and cited sources: Inflation can push stocks and bonds down together, which weakens the classic 60/40 hedge. [8] [4] [12]
SOURCES[8] Full Transcript: Hoffstein and Butler on Return Stacking excessreturnspod.substack.com[4] Morningstar: Higher inflation and stock-bond correlations global.morningstar.com[12] Markov-switching analysis of the 60/40 hedge raw.githack.com
AI-assisted, not human-edited. Methodology Corrections Who owns this site
- What happened
- Inflation can push stocks and bonds down together, which weakens the classic 60/40 hedge. [8] [4] [12]
- Original source
- Excess Returns podcast episode, independent perspective
- Brief by
- AT Pulse research desk AI-assisted; publisher and contact on the desk page
- When
- November 12, 2026 podcast episode published
- Covered
- Nov 15 edition
- Evidence
- 16 sources across 16 sites; no transcript
- 1Stock Investors Fear an AI Bubble. Bond Investors Fear…podcasters.spotify.com
- 2Cambridge Associates: Is trend following structurally…cambridgeassociates.com
- 3ai-CIO: Portable Alpha Falls out of Favorai-cio.com
- 4Morningstar: Higher inflation and stock-bond correlationsglobal.morningstar.com
- 5Alternatives Watch: Trend H1 2025 lossalternativeswatch.com
- 6Return Stacking Symposium 2026returnstacked.com
Reach: not measured yet
Inflation can push stocks and bonds down together, which weakens the classic 60/40 hedge. In 2022 the 12-month US stock-bond correlation turned positive. The guests propose return stacking instead: each dollar buys roughly a dollar of core stocks and bonds plus a dollar of a diversifier, financed through futures, so investors add protection without selling either core holding. [8] [4] [12]
Trend following has a strong record in crises. The SG Trend Index gained 20.9% in 2008 and 27.4% in 2022, while global stocks fell sharply in both years. It then lost 20.4% from May 2024 to May 2025, a stretch made worse by the April 2025 tariff whipsaw. The guests see behaviour as the main risk: investors tend to abandon diversifiers during long drawdowns. [2] [5] [8]
The structure is designed to avoid the failure of pre-2008 portable alpha. That approach paired derivatives exposure with illiquid hedge funds, and when collateral shrank it could not be rebalanced, which led to heavy pension losses. Return-stacked ETFs keep both exposures in one liquid fund. One independent analysis estimates that RSSB beat its benchmark after costs, while conventional leveraged ETFs trail theirs by about 1% a year. [3] [15] [9] [8]
The evidence: in 2022, stocks and bonds moved together while trend indexes gained.
Read the full assessment
The implication: if chip and power costs keep inflation high, as some strategists warn, advisors may want diversifiers that don't require cutting core stock or bond holdings.
Executive brief
Trend-following, the diversifier this episode is built around, just had one of its worst stretches on record. The SG Trend Index fell 20.4% from May 2024 to May 2025, its second-largest drawdown since 2000. Over the same period global stocks gained 18.3% (Cambridge Associates). In this Excess Returns episode, Corey Hoffstein and Adam Butler argue for "return stacking": keep a full stock and bond portfolio and use futures to add managed futures on top. Their case is that inflation can push stocks and bonds down together. Their main caveat is behavioural: investors tend to give up on diversifiers during long drawdowns. Both guests run Return Stacked products, so this is commentary from interested parties.
What changed and event timeline
Portable alpha breaks; trend holds up
MassPRIM dropped portable alpha after losing nearly 50% in fiscal 2008, and other pensions cut back too (). The SG Trend Index gained 20.9% while MSCI ACWI lost 42.2% ().
The stock-bond hedge fails
The 12-month correlation between US stocks and bonds turned positive (). Trend gained 27.4% while ACWI fell 18.4% ().
May 2025: Trend's deep drawdown
The SG Trend Index fell 20.4%, and the April 2025 tariff whipsaw made it worse (;).
Return Stacking Symposium
Return Stacked held its "End of Either/Or" event for advisors and allocators in Chicago. Its themes later shaped the episode ().
AI selloff
The Nasdaq 100 fell 6.3% and the S&P 500 fell 4.4%. Causes cited were election results and weak chipmaker earnings. Ed Yardeni described it as an AI bubble "losing some air" ().
Capabilities and access
- Structure: $1 invested gives roughly $1 of core assets plus $1 of a diversifier (transcript).
- Example products: RSSB holds 100% global equities plus 100% US Treasuries, which is about 2:1 leverage (Dickens).
- Where to find them: the issuer sites returnstacked.com and returnstackedetfs.com.
Read the full section
- Structure: $1 invested gives roughly $1 of core assets plus $1 of a diversifier (transcript).
- Example products: RSSB holds 100% global equities plus 100% US Treasuries, which is about 2:1 leverage (Dickens). RSST pairs US stocks with managed futures (optimizedportfolio).
- Where to find them: the issuer sites returnstacked.com and returnstackedetfs.com.
Technical analysis for researchers and developers
- How the leverage works: the futures overlay sits on top of cash-funded core holdings.
- Measured cost: Dickens estimates RSSB's excess cost at −0.58%, meaning it beat its benchmark after costs.
- Collateral design: before 2008, portable alpha fully funded illiquid hedge funds. When equities fell, collateral shrank and positions couldn't be rebalanced.
Read the full section
- How the leverage works: the futures overlay sits on top of cash-funded core holdings. Treasury futures are roughly the cheapest way to get leverage, compared with the swaps most leveraged ETFs use (Dickens).
- Measured cost: Dickens estimates RSSB's excess cost at −0.58%, meaning it beat its benchmark after costs. Conventional leveraged ETFs trail theirs by about 1% a year. Benchmark error could be up to one percentage point.
- Collateral design: before 2008, portable alpha fully funded illiquid hedge funds. When equities fell, collateral shrank and positions couldn't be rebalanced. Keeping both exposures inside one liquid fund is meant to avoid this (chapter 38:13; transcript).
- Manager selection matters: over five years, the 95% range of managed-futures fund returns spans about 27 percentage points (AIMA).
Claims and evidence
- Inflation links stocks and bonds: supported by the 2022 data (Morningstar) and a Markov-switching study of 2022–23 (Lusiki).
- Trend delivers "crisis alpha": independent index data for 2008 and 2022 support it (Cambridge Associates).
- A stacked 60/40/20 would have returned about 7.4% a year versus 6.5%: this is a backtest by the strategy's own authors (RCM Alternatives).
Read the full section
- Inflation links stocks and bonds: supported by the 2022 data (Morningstar) and a Markov-switching study of 2022–23 (Lusiki).
- Trend delivers "crisis alpha": independent index data for 2008 and 2022 support it (Cambridge Associates).
- A stacked 60/40/20 would have returned about 7.4% a year versus 6.5%: this is a backtest by the strategy's own authors (RCM Alternatives). No independent replication was found.
Context and prior work
- Origins: Gordillo, Butler and Hoffstein introduced return stacking in 2021 (RCM Alternatives).
- Lineage: it descends from institutional portable alpha, which had about $75 billion in strategies before 2008 (Sensible Investments).
- AQR lesson: Hoffstein cites Cliff Asness's early AQR years.
Read the full section
- Origins: Gordillo, Butler and Hoffstein introduced return stacking in 2021 (RCM Alternatives).
- Lineage: it descends from institutional portable alpha, which had about $75 billion in strategies before 2008 (Sensible Investments).
- AQR lesson: Hoffstein cites Cliff Asness's early AQR years. Investors tend to sell unfamiliar strategies in drawdowns rather than add to them (chapter 00:00; Asness essay).
Limitations, safety and contested findings
- Low correlation isn't protection: a diversifier can still lose money on the day stocks fall (chapter 23:02).
- Tracking error over years: in 2008, some portable alpha portfolios fell 30% or more, and PennSERS paid about $2.5 billion to swap counterparties (Benzinga).
- Trend can lag for a long time: after the 2024–25 drawdown, Cambridge Associates judges the strategy cyclical rather than broken.
Read the full section
- Low correlation isn't protection: a diversifier can still lose money on the day stocks fall (chapter 23:02).
- Tracking error over years: in 2008, some portable alpha portfolios fell 30% or more, and PennSERS paid about $2.5 billion to swap counterparties (Benzinga).
- Trend can lag for a long time: after the 2024–25 drawdown, Cambridge Associates judges the strategy cyclical rather than broken. That is a judgment, not proof.
- Leverage comes with the structure: the episode treats collateral needs and the ability to sit through drawdowns as the binding constraints.
Business and practitioner implications
- Advisors: stacking lets them add diversifiers without explaining a cut to stocks or bonds.
- Allocators: due diligence should centre on how collateral is handled, how liquid the overlay is, and dispersion between managers.
- Macro backdrop: Reuters-quoted strategists flag AI-driven inflation from chip and power costs as an underpriced risk.
Read the full section
- Advisors: stacking lets them add diversifiers without explaining a cut to stocks or bonds. The episode argues that keeping the core visible reduces the regret clients feel.
- Allocators: due diligence should centre on how collateral is handled, how liquid the overlay is, and dispersion between managers. The 2008 failures came from liquidity, not from the idea itself.
- Macro backdrop: Reuters-quoted strategists flag AI-driven inflation from chip and power costs as an underpriced risk. That is the regime the guests say diversifiers are for (Reuters via HL).
- Disclosure: none of this is investment advice. The guests manage the products they discuss.
The source trail.
Sources (16)
Stock Investors Fear an AI Bubble. Bond Investors Fear Inflation. How Can You Diversify Without Selling Them?
Metadata only. Transcript unavailable: Audio transcription returned HTTP 429.
podcasters.spotify.com